The final image Philadelphia Phillies fans have of reliever Orion Kerkering from last season is one they would rather forget, as it came in the most painful moment imaginable and directly preceded the end of the team’s playoff run.
Kerkering was on the mound in extra innings of a do-or-die postseason matchup against the Los Angeles Dodgers, with the Phillies facing elimination. The situation was tense: the bases were loaded, two outs were recorded, and every pitch carried enormous weight. When Dodgers outfielder Andy Pages chopped a slow roller back toward the mound, the Phillies appeared to have a clear path out of the inning. The most straightforward play was to calmly field the ball and throw to first base, where Bryce Harper was positioned to secure the final out and extend the game.
Instead, chaos followed.
In a split-second decision that would haunt both Kerkering and the fan base, the young reliever rushed the play and attempted to fire the ball home to catcher J.T. Realmuto. The decision itself was unnecessary, but what followed was even worse. Kerkering’s throw sailed high and wide, completely missing Realmuto and skipping toward the backstop at Dodger Stadium. As the ball got away, the Dodgers wasted no time capitalizing on the mistake.
Hyeseong Kim raced home from third base, scoring the winning run and instantly ending the Phillies’ season. The Dodgers walked off with a 2–1 victory in Game 4 of the National League Division Series, advancing to the next round while Philadelphia was left to process another abrupt and heartbreaking postseason exit.
ESPN’s Alden Gonzalez captured the moment and its impact succinctly, noting that the errant throw rolled toward the backstop and allowed the decisive run to score. The play not only sealed the Dodgers’ win but also eliminated a Phillies team that entered the postseason believing strongly it had what it took to win a championship.
For Kerkering, the error was a brutal way to close an otherwise promising year. The hard-throwing reliever had been one of Philadelphia’s more intriguing bullpen arms, showing flashes of dominance and earning the trust of the coaching staff in high-leverage situations. However, playoff baseball offers no mercy, and one mistake—especially in an elimination game—can overshadow an entire season’s worth of progress.
For the Phillies, the loss represented another chapter in a growing list of postseason frustrations. Despite a talented roster and lofty expectations, their October run once again ended sooner than hoped, this time on a defensive miscue rather than a lack of offense or pitching depth.
As the team looks ahead to the new season, Kerkering’s misplay remains a painful memory but also a potential turning point. How he responds to that moment—whether it fuels growth or lingers as a setback—will be closely watched. For now, though, that errant throw stands as the last pitch of the Phillies’ season, a single moment that brought championship dreams to a sudden halt.
Philadelphia Phillies’ Orion Kerkering Will Deal With Mistake ‘Rest Of My Life’
Kerkering became just the second player in Major League Baseball history to commit an error that ended a playoff series and, while he fielded questions in the locker room directly after the game, it was not immediately clear how the young pitcher would overcome the setback and return to the mound next season.
Now, after an offseason of reflection, Kerkering has opened up about how he has processed the failure.
“Everyone knows that it’s there. The more you think about it, the more it’s going to drain you away,” Kerkering told The Athletic’s Matt Gelb. “It’s going to affect me for the rest of my life.”
Philadelphia Phillies’ Orion Kerkering Makes Big Changes After Los Angeles Dodgers Error
Though Kerkering is aware that the brutal moment will stick with him forever, he has been working hard to put it behind him mentally and prepare better for next season physically.
He has had conversations with Phillies legends Brad Lidge and Mike Schmidt about moving on from the error and has taken a renewed approach to his physical fitness after a grueling year.
Leave a Reply